|
" 1709/15 |
: |
' ' |
|
' |
|
' |
|
' |
|
' |
|
' - |
|
' |
" 919/15: |
|
" 1709/15: |
|
|
|
" 919/15: |
1. |
|
2. |
|
3. |
|
4.
|
" 1709/15: |
1. 2. 3. 4. |
- (' ' ", ' ' ) " 50603-01-14 6.1.2015 (' ' , " ' ' ) " 54256-09-14 " 51098-09-14 8.2.2015 |
: |
' "
|
(6.12.2016) |
|
" 919/15: |
" ; " |
|
|
" 1709/15: |
" |
, ? , 410 , "-1984, .
: . . . , , , . . .
. , , 15-6, , . , . , .
:
1. , . , "-1962 (: ), , " " ( 14 ). " " , , ( 15 ). , " " (). " ", " " ( - " " 91, 125 (2013) (: -)).
2. " , " ( 24 ). , (). , ( 25 ). , 6 " " (" 1858/14 ' , (3.4.2014) (: " 1858/14); : " (2008) (: ; " )).
3. ( 274 (1989) (: ); -, ' 95). " " , : 7 -14 15 -30 .
4. ; . ( ) , , ( " , " - " " , ' 49. : " ; -). .
:
5. 15-6 , , "-" . 3() (), "-1959 (: ) :
|
3.() - , . |
, . , . : 1,400-1,300 " , , , ( ), ( -, , " : " 1235, 1239 (2016) (: -, )).
6. , , . , , , , , "" . , , , , . , , , , . , .
7. . 10,000 " ; , . 4 , 4,000 ". , . , 6,000 " ( ) . 2,500 " , , 3,500 " ( ). , " " "" .
8. , . , , , 3,000 " . , 6,500 " , 500 " . . , , . ; .
9. . , , ; ; . , , .
. , .
10. , 3() , . , , 15-6 , . , , . " 919/15 30.11.2015, . , , .
. , , .
11. . , : 6-0 (" "); 15-6 (""); 18-15 (""), . , . , ( " ") , ; , " ". . , . , .
.
: 15-0
12. 15 (" 393/83 ' , " (3) 613, 616 (1984) (: ); " 210/82 ' , " (2) 14, 20 (1984) (: ); " 591/81 ' , " (3) 449, 459-456 (1982) (: )). , 6-0 15-6. , 15-6, 6-0.
6-0 (" ")
13. 6 " :
" , " (", , , ).
6. , ( 273-254 ( , 2001) (: ); 379-372 ( , 1993) (: )). , (, ' 288; " " 357, 360 (1979) (: )). , . , , (, ' 375-372).
14. 6-0 . 6, . (" 469/84 ' , " (3) 197, 199 (1985)) " " " " (" 4523/90 ' , " (5) 529, 531 (1991) (: ); , ' 20, , ' 454; 6-0 , ' 265-257). , ; ( , ' 616; " 426/65 ' " (2) 21, 26 (1966); , ' 271-269; , ' 372; " ' 268).
15-6 ("")
15. 15-6. " (: "). 6 ( " " 161, 174-168 (1997)). :
" " (, ", ").
6 12 -13 . , , ; . , "" ( , ' 455-454; , ' 274; , ' 383-382). , : "" ; "" . 6 (" "), , 6-0 (, ' 383-382).
16. 6 . , - . . , . , , "" (Charity) , (, ' 278-277; " , ' 458).
. , 15. , 1944 " :
" , , , " ( , ' 458).
17. 1947, , :
" " . , , , . , , , ; , , " ( 1/15/707 - ( ), " ' " (")).
, " 6 15. , 6 ( 15) 6 , . , . :
" " [ ' '] , . " , [...] " "" ( " " 255, 270 (")).
18. , , " 15; , :
" , . 15 [...] , 6 -15 ( , ") " ( , ' 459 ' 461).
(, : " 1375/93 ' " (1) 215, 219 (1996); " 93/85 ' " (3) 822, 828 (1985); " 254/76 ' " (3) 169, 173 (1977) (: ); " 166/66 ' " (2) 533, 536 (1966) (: ); ' 534/62 ' , " 2898, 2900 (1962)), 15-0.
19. : , 15-0, 15-6, . , 6-0 " " " "; 15-6 " . " "" , .
18-15 ("")
20. , 15-6. , 18-15, . ( , ' 20; , ' 456).
15-0
21. , " " 15-0, 15-6 . "[] " ( , , ). , (, ' 381-379). " ":
" , , , " ( , ' 20; , ' 461; , ' 536).
22. , . " , " ( , ' 461). . , , , , . -1,400-1,300 " ( " ( ") 1180-05-14 ' ' ' ' ', 5 (26.3.2015) (: " 1180-05-14); " ( ") 20511-10-10 ' , 29 (4.4.2013); " ( -) 789/05 ' ' ' ' ', 30-28 (16.1.2006)). (" 552/87 ' , " (3) 559, 602-601 (1988)). , . (" 3301/92 ' , 4-3 (8.7.1993); " 52/87 ' , " (4) 201, 205 (1989); " 764/87 ' (31.12.1987); -, , ' 1239), .
23. . , , . " ", , , , 15 18 ( , ' 616; , ' 456; " 135/80 ' , " (2) 358, 360 (1982)). , , ( , ' 301; , ' 357); . , , , (, ' 291). , , (, ' 384-382).
24. , , "" "", (, ' 301-300). "" , , (, ' 294). "" "" . , " " , " " (, ' 295). , ( , ' 531). "" , , . , , , 18 ( , ' 21; , ' 289).
25. . , ( , , , ). , . :
" '' , , []:
' ? , ? , , , '" (, ' 456-455).
:
", , , , , . , , " (; " 324/88 ' , " (3) 347, 351 (1988)).
26. , . , "" . :
" , . , , ( ) . , . , , " (, ' 536; , : , ' 458-456; , ' 172; " 109/75 ' " (2) 690, 695 (1975); " 508/70 ' ' ' " (1) 603, 609 (1971) (: ')).
, .
, (, ' 373, 7; , 134-119 (2004)).
, .
27. : , . , . , , . : ; .
28. . , , . , :
" , . - , " ( ' '; , ' 462; " 514/89 ' , 4 (31.12.1989); , ' 22; ', ' 609).
" " " ", "" , , , , (" 3432/09 ' , (23.6.2009); " 239/85 ' " (1) 147, 154-152 (1986);" 130/83 ' , " (1) 721, 727-725 (1984)).
( : " 2561/08 ' , 7 (20.7.2008) (: " 2561/08); " 1715/07 ' , 6 (26.8.2007)). ' ' :
" . , , " (" 5750/03 ' , 5 (8.6.2005) (: )).
" 2433/04 ' (2.10.2005):
" , , [...] , ( ), " ( ' '; , 6 (2.10.2005)).
" 919/15 (" ( ") 16785-09-12 " ' ", 23-22 (11.12.2013) (" 16785-09-12 )), , ( " ( ') 42906-02-14 " ' ", 56 (11.5.2016); " ( ') 25370-02-13 " ' ", 227-226 (12.10.2015)). , ; .
29. 3() . :
() 15-0. , -1,400-1,300 " . , . .
() , . , , .
() . , .
() 18-15 .
15-6: "
30. " , 15-6 . , , , , . , ". 1947 ( : ( ') 616800/6 ' , (16.12.2015); ( ') 972073/2 (1.6.2014); ( ') 290277/7 ' (29.5.2013)), " ( : ( ") 2019/", " 225, 247 ("); ( ') 1115/", " 333, 336 ("); () 152/", " 170, 172-171 ("); ( ") 103/", " 65, 92 ("); ' 283-282 ).
( : " 9606/11 ' , ( ) ' (20.5.2013) (: " 9606/11)).
30.11.2015. 25.1.2016 ( ) :
" [...] , , . " , " " , . " " , .
" ". , , . , , , , .
, , .
, , , , " ( ' ').
31. 6 " . 1947, 15-6 . . , , . , .
32. " " ( ') 50603-01-14 ' ' ' ' ' (6.1.2015) (: ' ') " 919/15 :
", [ " 6 ' '] . , , , , " (, 11; , ' 281).
, 15-6 .
33. 14.6.2015 " 919/15 (: ). . 15-6. " " (: ), .
34. "; 6 . ' ' " 919/15 ". , ' ' "[] , - - [...] ".
35. ' ', 6 , , . . , . ' ' , :
" , . , , . , . . - ( ), , ' ' .
. , , [...] , , " ( ' ').
6 ; .
.
" 919/15
36. 1999 15 , 2014. 2007-2002 , 10, 13 -15 . , . , . : ; 13,295 " 12,467 " ; , ", ; 6,000 ", 4,500 ".
37. 9,000 " . 11.12.2013 (' ' ) . , , , ( ). :
" , . , , , " (" 16785-09-12, 32).
38. ; . " 15-6 . . , 3() . , , . , , , .
39. , . " , , , , , ", " (, 39); , , , , .
40. . 6.1.2015 (' ' ", ' ' ) 2,875 " . , ". , (' ' ) , 15 . " 15 . , 15, . , 15-6 , , . , : 15-6 ; .
41. 6 , . , , , , " , " (, 14).
42. , , . . , :
" 6 , , , " ( ' '; ).
, , 25% ( " 318/05 ( ') 318/05 ' (30.1.2006) (: " 318/05) , . , " 318/05, , .
43. -3,500 "; , -2,250 " ( 4,500 "). , 1,750 " , -1,125 " , 2,875 " . .
44. . , , . , , . , . .
45. . , . , . , , ( ); .
46. , . , . "" , .
12.3.2015 , .
" 1709/15
47. " 1709/15 2000, 13 , 2013. 2003, 2007 -2009 7, 10 -13 . 7 : ; . 10,000 " ; 8,000 " . , , , , , . .
48. , , , , 4,500 " ; . " 318/05 .
49. , . (' ' , " ' ' ) . . , , ; . . " , [ ' '] [...] " ( ' '; " ( ') 54256-09-14 " ' ", 28 (8.2.2015) (: " 54256-09-14)).
50. . ' ' " 919/15 6 . 15-6, , . , .
51. . 15-6 . , , , .
52. , " 919/15. " , ". , , . , . , " ( , " 31, 221 ( -1989) ( 1991) (: " )) , : , ; ( " (2012) (: " )). .
53. " , ". , . , . .
54. , , 3() , . , . , " , 15-6 , 15-6 ; . , . . , , . , , .
7.3.2016 " 1709/15, " 919/15.
55. , 15-6. " ? , 15-6 , ? , . , , . . ; ; " .
56. , 15 . ' " , , " (" 2561/08, 7). , , .
57. , , (, ' 274). , , . , , 6 . ; , (, ' 232; " " , 699, 705-704 (2007); -; " , ' 4; , " ( ") 55785-02-12 " ' ", 15 (20.9.2012) (: " 55785-02-12)). , .
58. , -2000 (-, , ' 1239) ( 8-5). . , . , . , .
59. " 318/05 . , . 1,400 ", , , , . , , .
60. , . " , " (, 12). , :
" , , .
, , , .
, , ; ; " (, 14-12).
" " -25% , . ( ), ( ). , , , . . " , . " (, 14).
(" ( ') 41385-03-15 " ' " (21.1.2016). (" 1655/16 ' (10.8.2016); " 54256-09-14).
61. , - " ( ') 25027-02-14 ' (28.12.2014)). " , . " (, ' 5). , , 50%. " - . , , " (, ' 6). (11,000 " ) 50% . , " 318/05, 50% , .
' ', " 919/15 , .
62. ' - " 1180-05-14 ( ' ). ' ( 1,400 " , 700 " ) . , , . , , (, 8).
63. ' , . , : A ( ), 1,400-1,300 "; B , ; C : , ( ) ; D ; -E , .
64.
,
, : . :
, :
(
)
, .
(
),
(, 11-10).
' ,
. , ,
,
.
65. : , , . . . , , , .
66. . , , 50% , . , 50% , 3,000 " 1,500 " . , 2,000 " , 5,000 ". . , , .
67. ; " " ' . 2006 " . : " " ' (: ) , ; ; , . , , , .
68. , " " ' 2005 . , 18 :
18: |
. , , , . . |
, . , ; . , (" , ' 4). :
" . [...] , [...] , , . , , [...] , [...] , , [...] . " (, ' 29-28).
, . :
" , '' ' ' . , '' , ''. , , ' ' . , " (, ' 5-4).
, : ; ; ; , , ; ; ( ). , ( " ).
, "-2012, . 17.5.2017 ( ), "-2017, /4212/20 . , , .
69.
.
, ,
. ,
27
, :
27: |
(1) , , .
(2) [...] , , . |
70. " , ; ; " " ; " " ; (" , ' 10) . , ; :
" [ ' '] ' '. , , , , " (, ).
:
" 27 [ ' '], ' , , , '. , . , . - [...] " (, ' 55).
71. , (" "). 5 . , " " . , . . , , "" (, ' 56-55).
72. . " " , :
" , , . , . " (, ).
, , ( , ' 91-55).
. , . 6.12.2016 ; , .
73. : . , "" " " ( 5 ). , .
74. . , . ' :
" , , . [...] , , " (" 8915/15 ' , - (27.1.2016); " 1570/14 ' , (5.6.2014); " 8719/13 ' , (5.2.2014); " 57/08 ' , (6.3.2008)).
75. : 15-6 " . , . . , .
, , , .
"
76. , 3() . :
|
() - , . |
, , . , , 15-6 " 1947. , ; , . , , .
? .
"
77. 15-6, . ' -:
" , . , , - ' " 506/88 ' , " (1) 87, 167 (1994). , . , . , , ( : " : " 9, 30 (1992); " : : " 659, 670 (1993))" (" 9606/11, ' -; , ' , -).
, , 15-6 . , , , . , , , . .
in pari materia
78. , in pari materia. ' ' :
" , - , (MATERIA IN PARI). " (" 6728/06 "" ( ' , 6 (30.11.2006)).
79. , ( " 4790/14 ' , 30-27 (19.10.2014)). . 3() :
|
() [...] , , , . |
3 :
|
() . |
|
() . |
, , , . ( () ( ' 2), "-1981), :
" , ; . , . , [...] [ ' '] , ".
' (, ' 461; 28. 3 : " ( ") 59072-02-15 ' ' ' ' ' (3.7.2016) (: " 59072-02-15); " 41769-10-13 ' .. (27.8.2015); " ( ') 42513-09-14 . ' . (4.1.2015); " ( ") 1098/07 ' (31.8.2008)).
80. 3() " [...] ", 3 ( ) . ' 3 , , . ' " ", 3 , . , , " , , , , 3() " (, ' 464). ' " ". ' " 3() , 3 . [...] 3() , ( ), " ( " 3 ? (" 591/81 ' )" 58, 67 (1983)).
81. . 3 ", 15-6 ( 3 ). , . , . , " 15-6, , . , 15-6 18-15, ( 20).
82. " 15-6 . , " " (" 10060/07 ' , 28 (2.10.2008) (: " 10060/07); . " 9201/08 ' (5.4.2009)). :
" , [...] ' ', . ' . --, , -, , ' [...] . " (" 3411/16 ' , 18-17 (20.6.2016)).
83. ( , 2), . " " , , (" 3984/15 ' , (13.9.2016) (: " 3984/15); " 4407/12 ' , 15 (7.2.2013) (: " 4407/12); " 7916/03 ' , " (5) 183, 190-189 (2005); " 4407/12, 20-10 ). , :
" , . , , , . , , '' , (, 11 ; " 3984/15, ).
:
" 12 [ ' '] , , . , , [...] , , - , , - , - [...] - [ ' '] , , - ( [ ' ']), " (" 614/76 ' , " (3) 85, 96-94 (1977)).
84. " ; , . , , . . , , , " , ( 27 " ). , .
85. , . "" , ; ; . , , . , , , , . 15-6.
86. , . , , . . , , . , . . "" ; .
87. , . , " " . (, , ); , , , . : , , . , .
88. , , . , ( , ) , . , , , . , . "" ; , "" . , , ( ' " 1180-05-14, 7; -, , ' 1260-1259).
89. , , ( -, ' 148). , , .
, " " ( 72), , .
, , .
90. . , , , . , ; ; . (-, ' 160-158). , ; ; , , .
91. " 919/15 36. , 8,795 ", 6,467 ". 2,875 " 50% 3,592 " , . 11,670 " . , . . , . , , , ( 8-5). .
92. , " 15-6 , . . , . : . , ". , , , . ; , .
93. : . , , , . , , . , , , . " , , . , .
15-6 , , . .
94. , " " :
" . -, -, , . , " ( -, ' 159).
, , , :
" [...] - [...] , , , ( ). , , -. ( ), . , . , , - , . , - , . , . , , . - , , - , [...] " (-, , , ' 1250; -, ' 159; ' " 1180-05-14, 10).
95. , . , . 15-6 ( 6-0) . , , . , , , , , ( , ). " .
96. , , , ( , ), . , , " .
97. , " , . , , , , , ( " 59072-02-15, 6; , , , ' 1251). , .
98. . ; ; . , " ":
" , , , , , . , , -" ( -, ' 148).
, , . . , ( -, ' 160-158; " " " (2008); " , ' 17-15; " ). : , .
99. , . , , , . . , , ( -, ' 160-159). , , " " .
, ; . , .
100. , , , 24 , ( 2). .
101. , . , (" 442/15, ; " 442/83 ' , " (1) 767, 770 (1984)). , , . , 15-6, , " " (" 3984/15, ).
: " 15-6, . .
102. 15-6 . :
" , . ' ' , " (" , ' 21).
(, : " 343/09 ' , " (2) 1, 41 (2010) (: ); " 2000/97 ' , " (1) 12, 30 (1999); " 721/94 - " ' , " (5) 749, 760-759 (1994) (: (; " 153/87 ' , " (2) 221, ' 247 ( ) ' (1988)).
103. , , (, : " 1703/92 .. " ' , " (4) 193, 204 (1998); , ' 761). , . ( , ' 42-41; " 4541/94 ' , " (4) 94, 132 (1995) (: )). "" , (" 746/07 ' , " (2) 530, 558 (2011); " 2671/98 ' , " (3) 630, 659-657 (1998) (: ); , ' 132). , , , :
": , , , , , " (" 453/94 ' , " (5) 501, 523 (1994) (: ); : , ' 660-659; ' 130-129).
104. , . , , "-1951 ", , " (" 202/57 ' , " 1528, 1537 (1958)) ( " 2911/05 ' , " (4) 406, 451-450 (2008) (: )), ( 3() , , "-2000). ( ) ' :
" ; - ; , , . - . - . , , - . . , " (" 6845/00 ' , " (6) 663, 688 (2002)).
105. "" . , . , , ( " " 145, 146-145 (1995); : " 6427/02 ' , " (1) 619, ' 721-717 ' ' 804-800 ( ) ' (2006)). . ' ' :
" [...] [...] . , , , , . [...] , [ , , "-2000 ' '] '' , , . [...] . , , . , , , , " (" 8821/09 ' ' ", 25-24 (2011) (: ')).
, .
106. . , , - , . . , , ' , :
" [...] . [...] ; ; . [] . " (, 26; : " 104/87 ' , " (4) 749, 761 (1990)).
107. , , , , "" (, " " . : ', 28; , ' 527-516). , , , , , .
108. , " . . , ; , .
109. . , ", , " (" 8425/13 ' ' , 72 (22.9.2014)). " " , , , .
110. , 2(1)(B) Divorce Act, R.S.C 1985, c. 3 (Can.), 1997 (Federal Child Support Guidelines, SOR/97-175 (Can.) (: ); 1 Canada, Department of Justice, Children Come First: A Report to Parliament Reviewing the Provisions and Operation of the Federal Child Support Guidelines, 4 (2002)). , . ( 40 ) : , ; , ; , , , ( , ' 9; Contino v. Leonelli‑Contino, [2005] 3 S.C.R. 217, 241-246 (Can.)).
111. , ("Parent with Care") ("Non-Resident Parent") ((Child Support Act 1991, c. 48, sch. 1 (Eng.)). , , ( ( (, ' 7). , (United Kingdom, the Child Maintenance Service Administers, How We Work Out Child Maintenance a Step-by-Step Guide 29 (2013); Christine Skinner, Child Maintenance In The United Kingdom, 14 Eur. J. Soc. Sec. 231, 242-243 (2012)).
112. , , 4 (Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989, sch. 4 (Austl.)) . , . . , , . , , ; (Ministerial Taskforce on Child Support of the Commonwealth of Australia, In the Best Interests of Children: Reforming (the Child Support Scheme 8 (2nd ed. 2005)).
113. , , . , . . ; , .
114. . , , , , . , ( -, ' 113-110). , , (, ' 274). , ( -, ' 114), .
115. . , , , ( -, " : ()-" 767, 771 (2004) (: -); -, ' 147 ' 156; " : " 275, 279-278 (2005) (: ); " ! " 671, 716-713 (2005); " 1988" 159, 173 (1990)).
116. , 75% ( : - 2016, ' 1 (6.3.2016) (: ) ( )), ( 48.8 " 58.3 " ; -7,439 " 11,114 " : , 2016, 12.46, 1.9.2016 ( ) (: 2016; 12.46)); (36.7 45.2 ); (32.4% , -13.4% ( , ' 4), , ( 2016, 12.21, ) ( -, ' 808-805).
117. , " " . , (32.2%) ( , ' 1); ( 12.46). , (" 1758/11 ' ( ) ", " (3) 593 (17.5.2012); , ' 279).
, -76.6% , , -75% , -23.4% ( ). , - 76.7% , -23.3% ( ).
119. . , ; ; . , , .
120. , . ( , -23.4% 100-75% ; -28.7% 75% ) .
121. , 15-6, . , , , . , " 15-6 , , .
122. , , ( -, ' 768). , . "" , . , .
:
123. , . , , :
" - , - , . [...] , , [...] , , -, , " ( -, ' 160-158; : " : ? " 295, 308-306 (2015)).
, . , , , . , , . , , , , . ; . , ( ) .
124. , , . -75% . , . , ( ) , . , .
125. , ", . , , . , , ( , ' 654; " 7111/95 ' , " (3) 485, 502-501 (1996); " 720/82 ' , " (3) 17, 21 (1983)). ; . .
126. . . " " , . , . , .
:
127. , , , ; :
" , [ ' '] '' , , , " (" 318/05, 14).
-:
" ' ' [ ' '], , , - " ( -, ' 159).
, , ; , ( -, ' 159; , -, " " 335, 340-339 (2002); Richard Neely The Primary Caretaker Parent Rule: Child Custody and the Dynamics of Greed 3 Yale L.& Pol'y Rev. 168, 171-177 (1984))).
128. , . . , . , , (, ' 416). , , . , , , ( " " (2009)); " " " 3151/14 ' , 39-32, 46 (5.11.2015) (: " 3151/14)). , :
" . , , , , . -- , . , , " ( " : ?" 27, 31-30 (2007) (: )).
129. . , ; ( ). , , (; ' " " 381, 383 (2006)). , . , , ; . " " ( . : " -: ( ") 9322-29-1 (19.3.06) " 155, 163 (2009)).
130. , "" (" , ' 417; " 3151/14, 5 ' (5.11.2015)). :
" - . . : , . , [...] , . " ( , 31).
, " " "" ( 83). , . , :
" , , . , , , . , " (" 4407/12, 16; " 3984/15, ).
, . , "" . , ; .
131. . :
" . ' ', , , . . . " (" , ).
, ; , . , ; . .
132. , , . ' " 1180-05-14 " , " (, 14). ' :
" , . , , , . '' . , . , , , . , , , , " (" (') 384/06 ' ' ' '(') ', 1 (27.3.2007)).
133. , , ( 87-86) "" :
" '' . 2-3 , ; , , , , , , , , . " (" 1180-05-14, 14 ' ).
134. , , ( ); . 24 , 25 . , , (, : " 10060/07, 28; " 27/06 ' , 11 (1.5.2006) (: " 27/06); " 9358/04 ' , 9 (2.5.2005)). , , , , , ( : " 27/06, 18).
135. , . , , (" 27/06, 15-14; " 5227/97 ' - , " (1) 453, 462 (1998); " 9201/08 , 19; " 4238/03 ' - , " (1) 481, 488 (2003) (: )).
136. (" 10060/07, 32; " , 25-16 (2011) (: " ); -, ' 121-119). ; , (" ( ') 19190-07-14 ' ' ' , 49 (19.10.2014); " ( ') 23494-01-10 . ' ., 20 (29.8.2013). " ( ') 38844-10-13 ' (10.2.2014). " 1858/14; 9() , " " (" , ' 67)).
137. : , , , ( ); , , , ; , ; , ; ; ; ( : " ( ") 15617-04-15 ' , 12-10 (16.7.2015); " 38844-10-13 ; " ( -) 35652-07-12 ' ' ' ' ' ' ', 14 (9.12.2012)).
138. , , ; ( ""); ; ; ; ; ( : " ( ') 24238-06-16 ' ' ' ' ', 20 (19.7.2016); " 55785-02-12, 30; " ( ') 12148-04-10 ' ' ' ' ', 59 (28.4.2011). : (" ( ') 9963-06-11 ' (10.8.2011)).
139. , ; . , , , . .
140. . ( ), :
" - , " (" 2898/03 ' , " (2) 550, 561-560(2004) (: " 2898/03)).
, (, ' 563). . , :
" [ ' '], ' '. [...] , , - ... , , , '" ( ' '; " 1745/13 ' , (9.1.2014); : " 4407/12, 15; " 6378/04 ' (19.8.2004); " 2898/03, ' 564-563; " 10109/02 ' , " (2) 875, 880 (2003); , ' 486; " ' ': ' ' " 571, 605-604 (2013)).
141. : , . , . " ", . , , . , , ; , .
: "
142. " 15-6 . , , ; ; . ( in pari materia); ; , . , , , .
" 15-6 , , , .
143. , . ( 20() -: ) , :
" - . . , , , . , , [...] , , - " (" 5/84 ' , " (3) 374, 384 (1991); " 3749/12 - ' , 18 (1.8.2013); 247-240 (2004) (: ))
144. , . - , , . , . , (, 242). , , ( " 1630/16 ' ", 3 (23.3.2016); " 1336/16 ' , 1 (3.4.2016)) .
145. , , , .
146. , ' -, :
() ( 125 ).
() " 15-6 ; , . , , " ". , , (" " ) ( 97 ); , .
() , , ( 61 ), 142 , ; .
147. 15-6 . , , . , , . , , . , , , . , , , . , , "; .
, 15-6 , , , , .
, .
.
' -:
1. ? 15-6 , , . ' . . , . , - , , .
: ?
2. : . , , , . , , . , . , , .
:
3. . , . ? " "? ? , , . , , , .
:
4. "" . , , . ? , , , , . , - . , 15-6 , , ", . , , , . , 15-6 ( : " 9606/11 ' (20.5.2013)).
5. "" 6 . , (, : -, " : " 1235 (: -, )). , . , , .
?
6. , , - " " " ". ( " ") , ( " ").
7. , . .
8. . , . , , . , , .
9. , , , ( ). , , "" . , , , .
10. , ( -, ). , , ( ). ' , -25% , (: " (') 318/05 ' (30.1.2006) (: " 318/05)). - , ( : " (') 12107-04-10 . ' . (25.1.2011)). , . , , " " (: " () 50603-01-14 ' ' ' ' ', 23 (6.1.2015). : " () 25027-02-14 ' (28.12.2014)). , , .
11. , , . , , . , , . , , . , .
:
12. , " " , , . - , , .
13. " " . "" . , , (: " 2266/93 , ' , " (1) 221, 237-236 (1995); " 7395/07 ' , 15 (21.1.2008)). 20.11.1989 (: ), 1991. , ? ? , , , "" , .
14. , . ? , . - , , . , , , , .
15. .
16. :
" , , , " (, 3(1)).
17. . . , .
18. , ( ) . , , (:Lenore J. Weitzman, The Divorce Revolution: The Unexpected Social and Economic Consequences for Women and Children in America (1985). : - " " 821, 824-823 (2016), ; -, , ' 1259). . " " ( :Margaret F. Brinig, Does Parental Autonomy Require Equal Custody at Divorce?, 65 LA. L. Rev. 1345, 1369 (2005)). , .
19. , , " ", . , "" . .
20. , . , , . , , , .
21. , .
22. , (: " 98/69 ' , " (1) 693, 699-698 (1969)). , , , . , , , ( : " 5853/05 " ' ", " (16.1.2007); " 1811/09 " ' , 17-16 (6.1.2010)), (: " 528/88 ' , " (4) 297, 303-299 (1989); " 453/94 ' , " (5) 501, 516 (1994)). ' ( ) " 2671/98 ' , " (3) 630 (1998) (: " 2671/98):
" , - . , . , , , " (, ' 651).
23. , . , (: " 727/00 ' , " (2) 79, 89 (2001); " 6778/97 ' , " (2) 358, 365 (2004); " 1067/08 " " ' , " (2) 398, 429 (2009)).
24. . , , , , . (: " 2671/98, ' 654; " 11163/03 ' , " (1) 1, 32 (2006); " 343/09 ' , " (2) 1, 49-46 (2010)).
25. "" "-" . , , "", . . , , (: " 8821/09 ' ' " (16.11.2011); " '" 109, 132-130 (2013); 300-298 (2016); Deborah Hellman, When Is Discrimination Wrong? 27-29 (2008)).
26. . , . "" .
27. , , . , , "" - . , , . , , .
28. ? , .
29. 15-6 , , " ". , , , . , , , .
30. . " " , , . , , , , . , , , , . .
31. . . , , , , . , , . , , .
:
32. . ( ) , . , , . " " .
33. : , (: " - , "-1995" 431, 432-431 (1997)). , . , ( : Margaret F. Brinig, Unhappy Contracts: The Case of Divorce Settlements, 1 Rev. L. & Econ. 241 (2005)). , , . "" .
34. , ( ), . , , " " (: 423 (1995)).
35. , . , . , , . , . , - . "" . , , " ". , , , . , -, , "" . .
36. : " " "", , "" . - (: " 36 (2012) (: " ); - " " 91, 158-157 (2013) (: -), ). (" 1709/15) , 3.12.2014:
"... [ ' ' '] .
.
".
37. , . , , . , " ", .
38. : , "", . " ", , . "", ( 98 . : -, ' 159, ; Ilan Katz et al., Shared Care Parenting Arrangements since the 2006 Family Law Reforms: Report to the Australian Government Attorney-Generals Department, Social Policy Research Centre, University of New South Wales 9-10 (2010)). " " (Belinda Fehlberg et al., Caring for Children after Parental Separation: Would Legislation for Shared Parenting Time Help Children?, 7 Fam. Pol.y Briefing 1, 9 (Oxford University, 2011) (: Fehlberg)). , . , , , . , , .
39. 15-6 , . : . . , . . , .
40. ( : " 5750/03 ' , 5 (8.6.2005), ; " 2433/04 ' , 6 (2.10.2005)). (: , ' 56-55). , , . , , .
:
41. , , , , . , : (, , ) ( , , , ). , , . , , . . , . : - , . ? ? ? ? ? ? ? , , - "" . , , . .
42. , . ?
43. " " . , , , , . , , .
44. , , . . . . , . , ( 34 ) "" - , . , , . , . , " " , . , , . " " , .
45. , , . , " ". , , . " , " ( 101 ). , . .
46. , . " ". . , , . , .
47. : . , , , - . , . , .
48. . . "" ( : " 1954/14 ' , 5-4 (4.8.2014); ' "" 153, 195-185 ( ' , 2012)). , , , "-1973, , , "-1969. , (, , , ). , . , . , .
: " " " "
49. "" . , ? , : . " " (, , ). - , . . .
50. " "? . , , , . , (, , , ) . , . "" , - .
51. , . , . , ( ), , (: -, ' 159; 98 ). , , .
52. , , - "" , . . , . , - , (: Fehlberg , ' 9; Belinda Fehlberg, Christine Millward & Monica Campo, Shared Post-separation Parenting in 2009: An Empirical Snapshot, Aust. J. Fam. L 12-13 (2009).). , . .
53. . " " , . , , . , , - .
54. : " ". , . , , ( ). - - ( ; ). , ( ). , .
55. , , -" 318/05 "" . , . , " " 25% , , . , , .
56. , . ( ) 1,500 ( ) 2,500 ( ). , , - 1,250 , . 31.25% - .
57. " " , . , "", (, , ) . , " " , "".
58. . . , ( , : Katharine T. Bartlett & Carol B. Stack, Joint Custody, Feminism and the Dependency Dilemma, 2 Berkeley Women's L. J. 9, 39-40 (1986)). , ( ). , . ( , ) , . , , ( , ) ?
59. , . , , . - ( ) . , , . ( ) . , . , , " " . , .
60. , , . , "" .
61. , , , 15-6:
() "" ( , ).
() , " " ( , , ). , ( ). , , - . , .
() , - .
() , .
:
62. , . , . , , , . , , , " ". , . , . , .
: - ?
63. , "" . , , - . , , , . , "" "" . - , , (: " 1000/92 ' , " (2) 221 (1994)).
64. , , , , "" , (, ).
65. , . " " "" , . , .
66. : "" . , , "" ( , "-1951, 5 ). "".
67. , , . - . , , . , , . , .
68. , , - . , - , . " " (: " 3151/14 ' , 49-47 (5.11.2015)). , . ? "" . : "" -, " " . . , . , . " " (: " 4623/04 ' (26.8.2007)), " " . . , . , .
69. 15-6, . , .
70. , . . , . - .
71. , . .
' :
1. , 15-6 ("") " " - , ; , " 6 (" ") 15-6.
2. ' 15-6 , - - .
3. 15-6, , ( ), , , , " (1989), ( 3 (), "-1959 17-14, 25-24 , "-1962).
, ( , , - ' , 12-11; " ' " ' , ' 6-5), " . " , .
4. , . , , .
5. - 15-6 ( 10 ). , 15-6 , . . , ' :
"... , , : , , - , ( ). , : , (" 425/68 , ' , " (1) 309, 324-323 (1969)).
, ( : " 386/78 ' , 8 (31.7.1979); " 130/84 ' , " (3) 358, 360-359 (1985); " 5265/92 ' (10.2.1994); " 5750/03 ' , 5 (8.6.2005); " 1356/08 ' , - (26.3.2008); " " - " [ ], : "). " ", . " -
" . "" . , , , , . - , , - - . , , " " " , , ( ), - , , . , , , , ... , ...; " (" (-) 2480/04 .. ' ., 29 (8.6.2006)).
- " : ()-" 767 (2004)).
, , .
6. - - - . , , .
, , , - . , . , . , , . , , . , .
- , . , , "" . . , , , , .
7. - , . - ( ). ' - , . , - ( - " - " 91, : -) " " , " " ( - " "), ( 54-49).
, . " " " ", ( ). " " (" "). " " , , , . , .
8. - 15-6, , , . . . , 15-6 . , -, , , - , -, , .
, . , - , . ( - 159; -, " : " 1235). . , . ( ) . " " " ", -, " " . .
" , , , . ( ) ( ). , .
9. - ( 141-127 ). , . , , , " " , .
10. .
' :
1. , ' , 15-6 , , , . , ( 145 ).
, .
2. , . , , , . . , , ; . , -. , . , . ' , , , -- : " ... : , . , . [] , . " ( () , ). , , . , , . ' ' ", . . . , ''.
3. ' ' 15-6, , . ' ' ' "' (-1800 ), - ( ' ' , ' " 919/15; 2-1 ). " , - , , . , , , .
4. , ( 147() ). , : , '' ( , , ). ' '; , , '' , .
5. : . - , . - , - . , ' ( ) ', '' . , . , : . ; , , . . , . ( ) , , . , , , , . , '' , . , ( ) , , . : , . , '' , , (-) - ?
6. : . , , 6-0, , . , ( ), . , ( 4), . , . , . , , , .
' :
' .
, , - 61 142 .
' ':
' 15-6 , , . - ' - , . , , . , , , . , , " " . , .
䠠
' :
1. ' " 15-6 , . " 3() (), "-1959 (: ) . , , . , , - , .
2. , , . ' -, " : " 1235 (") " ", " " " -". " " , . , , , , 3() 15-6.
3. , - 15-6 , 1. ' - " " ( 44 -). " " , . ' ' - - 61 , , , . - - 15-6 .
' .
15-6 , , , , .
, 61 ' -, . , .
.
, " " (19.7.2017).
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
________________________
. 15009190_M29.doc
, ' 077-2703333 ; , www.court.gov.il